Hello dear
Welcome To Cascarelli's Pizza
Cascarelli's Pizza, nestled in Homer, MI, invites pizza lovers to indulge in a delightful culinary experience. Known for its classic offerings and unique menu items, this eatery serves a variety of mouthwatering pizzas, including the renowned House Pizza and Porky's Pizza. Guests can also enjoy fresh salads and flavorful flatbreads. The inviting atmosphere tells a story of nostalgia with its vintage decor. Customers praise the attentive staff and the high-quality, freshly-made food, noting the standout flavors and generous toppings. Whether you're sampling the famous Frankie's Pie or the cheesy lasagna, Cascarelli's promises a satisfying dining adventure.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Annie's Bread
Classic Olive Burger
Fettuccine Alfredo
6 Inch Pizza
About
Cascarelli's Pizza
Welcome to Cascarelli's Pizza, a true gem nestled in the heart of Homer, Michigan. Located at 103 E Main St, this pizzeria is more than just a place to grab a slice; it's a sanctuary for those seeking deliciously crafted pizzas and a vibrant dining experience. With their signature combination of fresh ingredients and generous toppings, Cascarelli's has become a beloved spot for both locals and visitors alike.
As you step inside, the atmosphere might take you back in time with its dated decor filled with nostalgic photographs. However, many patrons find this ambiance charming. It sets the stage for a genuine, family-friendly dining experience. As one frequent diner, Mary London, beautifully stated, “The pizza was AMAZING! Generous toppings but still had a crunch crust.” It’s clear that while the surroundings evoke the past, the flavors are rooted deeply in the present.
The menu boasts an array of unique items guaranteed to satisfy every palate. From the “Father Mother Uncle Burger” to comfort food like mac & cheese and fettuccine alfredo, Cascarelli's caters to all ages, including a delightful kid's menu for the little ones. Among the crowd favorites is the "Frankie's Pie," which combines their famous meatballs with red onions, mushrooms, and fresh basil atop a thin crust. This dish is a testament to their dedication to quality and taste, leaving diners like Brian Zientek eager to return for more.
Service at Cascarelli's is equally commendable. Staff members have been described as attentive and friendly, ensuring patrons feel valued and well taken care of, even during busy hours. As Hosie Bush IV noted, “The staff were friendly and very attentive. The food was delicious.” It’s no wonder many find themselves recommending this establishment over others with similar names.
So, if you're in the area or simply passing through, make it a point to stop at Cascarelli's Pizza. You won’t just enjoy a meal; you’ll create lasting memories over expertly crafted dishes that leave you craving more. Don't just take our word for it—experience the unique charm and flavors of Cascarelli's for yourself.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The atmosphere is sort of dated with hundreds of pictures of the past. I would rather see a more modern decor. There are many unique menu items. Food is made fresh and the pizza area is open to watch. It is recommended. ”
“ Worth the wait! They were slammed on a Friday night (rightfully so) staff was considerate and warned us up from about a wait for pizza, in the meantime they were kind and attentive. We had Annie’s bread while we waited, 10/10! The pizza was AMAZING! Generous toppings but still had a crunch crust. Can’t wait to return! ”
“ Very nice place. Roomier than it looks from the outside. It runs deep and is accommodating for large groups of people. The staff were friendly and very attentive. The food was delicious. My first cut into my lasagna was all cheese! Yummy! ”
“ Pizza is great. The atmosphere is awesome. We went to the "other" one, and they were rude. So got back on the road, and stumbled across this place. Glad it happened. Definitely recommended over the other of the same name. ”
“ What a cool place! People had recommended we try this place for a while, so on our drive back home from South Haven, MI we decided to detour a bit and stop. They did not disappoint! I got the Frankie's Pie which has their famous meatballs, red onion, mushroom & basil...it was incredible! Thin, cracker style crust and the sauce was great, slightly sweet but not too much. My wife had the lasagna and she really liked that too. We took leftovers home of course! ”
“ Great pizza. I'd heard about it via a travel group and one day I was in mood for a drive. Given a 1.5 hour drive it didn't disappoint. The food was great with a nice home made and authentic taste. ”
“ The food and service were outstanding. I don't know where the receipt is but we had a young lady with blonde hair wait on us and she was great at her job ”
“ Always love the food here, the service is always top-notch, and the atmosphere is a great dining experience you do not want to miss, and the chandeliers are really cool too!! ”